He actually takes a step back from the anger radiating off of her. What she feels is valid, and he doesn't think there's anything he can say to diffuse it, but that protective thing stays curled up inside him like a fist. Which is why he balks at Bay's question at first: he's not sure how much he's supposed to reveal, or if it's his place to reveal anything at all.

"Yes and no," he settles on. His expression has turned guarded.

"Well, mostly yes. All that stuff about getting kicked out of heaven is true, at least in one version of the world. But that doesn't mean you should believe everything that's in the Bible. What's that saying, about history being written by the winners?"