From the sounds of it, maybe he shouldn't have jumped into the we are not them talk so quickly. Michael takes down the black tea. He leaves it on the countertop not far from the boiling water and moves back to watch Claire going through her things with perhaps too much focus. This is a conversation that should happen in the same room, he thinks, without raising his voice for her to hear.

"Have you spoken to Jon yet?"

Back to his full self, Michael is also back to being unable to forget anything. They remained close friends throughout the centuries; he remembers the longest and most recent of her relationships. It might not have been precisely real but they had all lived that shared hallucination day by day as if it were. Apart from the loss of their godly forms and abilities, there's nothing that says they can't pick up where they left off.

Depending on her pseudo-husband's disposition, of course, hence the question. He could be another man entirely now.